Inside the palace walls
Unbeatable for atmosphere and terrible for sleep. Bars run until two in summer and the stone carries every sound, so a conversation outside the bar below your window sounds like it is inside the room. Choose it if you are here for two nights and want the experience of stepping out of your door into the Peristyle; avoid it if you are travelling with children, or if you want to sleep before midnight, or if you have heavy bags — the lanes are cobbled and there are no cars inside the walls.
Varoš
Five minutes from the Riva, on the slope under Marjan, all stone houses and steps. The best compromise between atmosphere and sleep, and the konobas are here, which means you eat well without walking home. The steps are the catch — it is a hill, and some of the lanes are stairs rather than streets, so ask your host about luggage before you book if you are travelling heavy.
Bačvice and Firule
Ten to twenty minutes east, with the sand, the beach bars and a lot of the nightlife. Good for a swim before breakfast, less good if you want silence at midnight. The area is flat, which is a relief after the palace and Varoš, and the beaches are close enough that you will use them. Firule is the quieter end, Bačvice the louder.
Meje and Žnjan
Meje is quiet, green and residential, with sea views and a fifteen-minute walk into town along the Marjan path. It is the most expensive of the neighbourhoods and the one with the least nightlife, which is either the point or the problem. Žnjan is further out, newer, cheaper per square metre and best if you have a car or small children — it is the modern beach strip, with promenades and space, and a bus ride or a forty-minute walk from the old town.
The honest version
If it is your first time and you have two or three nights, stay in Varoš. If it is a beach holiday with kids, stay in Žnjan or Firule. If you want the palace experience and can sleep through anything, stay inside the walls for one night and move out for the rest. Meje is for people who have been before and know they want quiet. Bačvice is for people who want to swim at seven and go out at eleven, and do not mind that everyone else in Bačvice is doing the same.
Each of these has its own page in the neighbourhood guide.
Old Town & Diocletian's Palace
Varoš
Bačvice
Meje
Žnjan
Things to do in Split
Split in two days
The best beaches in Split